Mattingly Sale

Mattingly quality assurance and price concessions. Find great deals for Mattingly on eBay.


  • 2017 Triple Threads Derek Jeter Don Mattingly Reggie Jackson 3x Patch Jersey #9

2017 Triple Threads: $32.00

2017 Triple Threads Derek Jeter Don Mattingly Reggie Jackson 3x Patch Jersey #9

  • 1984 Donruss #248 Don Mattingly New York Yankees RC Rookie w Crease

1984 Donruss #248: $13.50

1984 Donruss #248 Don Mattingly New York Yankees RC Rookie w Crease

  • 1984 Topps Don Mattingly Rookie #8 Yankees NMMT

1984 Topps Don: $16.00

1984 Topps Don Mattingly Rookie #8 Yankees NMMT

  • 2006 Exquisite Collection Don Mattingly Game used PATCH 510 Yankees RARELY SEEN

2006 Exquisite Collection: $24.00

2006 Exquisite Collection Don Mattingly Game used PATCH 510 Yankees RARELY SEEN

  • 2019 Topps Museum Collection DON MATTINGLY Framed Silver Ink AUTO #0915 Yankees

2019 Topps Museum: $22.50

2019 Topps Museum Collection DON MATTINGLY Framed Silver Ink AUTO #0915 Yankees

  • 2019 Topps Silver Pack 1984 Chrome Promo Don Mattingly Card #1 PSA 10

2019 Topps Silver: $35.00

2019 Topps Silver Pack 1984 Chrome Promo Don Mattingly Card #1 PSA 10

  • 1988 Fleer Don Mattingly  PSA 10  New York Yankees Captain

1988 Fleer Don: $14.95

1988 Fleer Don Mattingly PSA 10 New York Yankees Captain

  • 2019 Topps Definitive Don Mattingly Signed AUTO 1525 New York Yankees VARIATION

2019 Topps Definitive: $37.00

2019 Topps Definitive Don Mattingly Signed AUTO 1525 New York Yankees VARIATION

  • 2019 Topps Stadium Club DON MATTINGLY Oversized Box Topper Boxloader Yankees

2019 Topps Stadium: $19.99

2019 Topps Stadium Club DON MATTINGLY Oversized Box Topper Boxloader Yankees

  • 1987 FLEER DON MATTINGLY PSA 10 GEM MINT NEW YORK YANKEES CAPTAIN

1987 FLEER DON: $23.10

1987 FLEER DON MATTINGLY PSA 10 GEM MINT NEW YORK YANKEES CAPTAIN

  • DON MATTINGLY RC 1984 DONRUSS #248 ROOKIE NEW YORK YANKEES GRADED BGS 8.5

DON MATTINGLY RC: $17.50

DON MATTINGLY RC 1984 DONRUSS #248 ROOKIE NEW YORK YANKEES GRADED BGS 8.5

  • 2019 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB CHROME REFRACTOR DON MATTINGLY YANKEES NEW RARE!

2019 TOPPS STADIUM: $49.99

2019 TOPPS STADIUM CLUB CHROME REFRACTOR DON MATTINGLY YANKEES NEW RARE!

  • 1984 Topps Tiffany #8 Don Mattingly New York Yankees RC Rookie

1984 Topps Tiffany: $49.00

1984 Topps Tiffany #8 Don Mattingly New York Yankees RC Rookie

  • 1984 Topps #8 Don Mattingly Yankees RC PSA-9 Mint Graded Vintage

1984 Topps #8: $15.00

1984 Topps #8 Don Mattingly Yankees RC PSA-9 Mint Graded Vintage

  • 2017 Topps Archives '60 Throwback DON MATTINGLY Yankees PSA 10 Gem Mint

2017 Topps Archives: $25.00

2017 Topps Archives '60 Throwback DON MATTINGLY Yankees PSA 10 Gem Mint

  • 2003 Topps Retired Chrome Yankees Don Mattingly Certified Auto Autograph TA-DON

2003 Topps Retired: $49.99

2003 Topps Retired Chrome Yankees Don Mattingly Certified Auto Autograph TA-DON

  • 1986 FLEER #627 DON MATTINGLY In Action New York YANKEES Captain PSA 10

1986 FLEER #627: $29.95

1986 FLEER #627 DON MATTINGLY In Action New York YANKEES Captain PSA 10

  • NY Yankees SP Lot! Refractors Topps Mattingly Rookie 1984 2 AUTOs #d Parallels

NY Yankees SP: $39.99

NY Yankees SP Lot! Refractors Topps Mattingly Rookie 1984 2 AUTOs #d Parallels

  • 1987 Topps Tiffany PSA 9 MINT Lot Will Clark RC Mike Schmidt Ripken Mattingly

1987 Topps Tiffany: $19.00

1987 Topps Tiffany PSA 9 MINT Lot Will Clark RC Mike Schmidt Ripken Mattingly

  • 1984 Topps Baseball Don Mattingly Rookie Card - PSA Mint 9

1984 Topps Baseball: $31.00

1984 Topps Baseball Don Mattingly Rookie Card - PSA Mint 9

  • 2017 TOPPS FIVE STAR SILVER SIGNATURES DON MATTINGLY AUTO AUTOGRAPH 1525 NYY

2017 TOPPS FIVE: $48.50

2017 TOPPS FIVE STAR SILVER SIGNATURES DON MATTINGLY AUTO AUTOGRAPH 1525 NYY

  • 2019 Panini Leather & Lumber Don Mattingly Gameball AUTO 1920 Yankees

2019 Panini Leather: $20.00

2019 Panini Leather & Lumber Don Mattingly Gameball AUTO 1920 Yankees

  • Don Mattingly 1990-91 Star Nova Edition PROMO Blank Back ONLY 100

Don Mattingly 1990-91: $14.99

Don Mattingly 1990-91 Star Nova Edition PROMO Blank Back ONLY 100

  • 1984 Donruss DON MATTINGLY New York Yankees RC Rookie #248 - SGC 84 nm 7

1984 Donruss DON: $34.99

1984 Donruss DON MATTINGLY New York Yankees RC Rookie #248 - SGC 84 nm 7

  • 1984 Topps Tiffany #8 Don Mattingly Rookie YANKEES RC

1984 Topps Tiffany: $33.00

1984 Topps Tiffany #8 Don Mattingly Rookie YANKEES RC

  • 2014 Topps Tribute Don Mattingly Green Auto #d 1325

2014 Topps Tribute: $20.74

2014 Topps Tribute Don Mattingly Green Auto #d 1325

  • 1984 Topps Relic All-Star Complete Your Set 2019 Series 2 You U Pick Jersey Bat

1984 Topps Relic: $15.48

1984 Topps Relic All-Star Complete Your Set 2019 Series 2 You U Pick Jersey Bat

  • DON MATTINGLY Auto 2019 Topps Baseball 1984 Design Yankees 84A-DMA

DON MATTINGLY Auto: $40.24

DON MATTINGLY Auto 2019 Topps Baseball 1984 Design Yankees 84A-DMA

  • Don Mattingly - Lot of 80+ different stickers

Don Mattingly -: $34.00

Don Mattingly - Lot of 80+ different stickers

  • 2006 Topps Triple Threads Don Mattingly Steve Garvey Dan Johnson Auto GU 518 

2006 Topps Triple: $39.00

2006 Topps Triple Threads Don Mattingly Steve Garvey Dan Johnson Auto GU 518 

  • (4) 1984 FLEER DON MATTINGLY #131 ROOKIE LOT NM-MT YANKEES VL1613

(4) 1984 FLEER: $24.99

(4) 1984 FLEER DON MATTINGLY #131 ROOKIE LOT NM-MT YANKEES VL1613

  •  Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Rookie New York Yankees . Nice Condition

Don Mattingly 1984: $15.99

Don Mattingly 1984 Topps Rookie New York Yankees . Nice Condition

  • 1984 Donruss Baseball Complete Set (660) MINT w Mattingly Strawberry RC Rookie

1984 Donruss Baseball: $33.00

1984 Donruss Baseball Complete Set (660) MINT w Mattingly Strawberry RC Rookie

  • 1984 Fleer Set Break #131 Don Mattingly RC NM-MT OR BETTER *GMCARDS*

1984 Fleer Set: $14.50

1984 Fleer Set Break #131 Don Mattingly RC NM-MT OR BETTER *GMCARDS*

  • 1984 Fleer Don Mattingly PSA 10 GEM MINT

1984 Fleer Don: $335.00

1984 Fleer Don Mattingly PSA 10 GEM MINT

  • 1995 Topps Finest Refractor wpeel Don Mattingly New York Yankees #126

1995 Topps Finest: $25.00

1995 Topps Finest Refractor wpeel Don Mattingly New York Yankees #126

  • 2007 Sweet Spot Classic Signatures Don Mattingly Silver Stitch Black 515  Auto

2007 Sweet Spot: $15.00

2007 Sweet Spot Classic Signatures Don Mattingly Silver Stitch Black 515  Auto

  • 1984 Topps Complete Set (792) NM-MT Mattingly  Strawberry Rookies RC

1984 Topps Complete: $44.99

1984 Topps Complete Set (792) NM-MT Mattingly Strawberry Rookies RC

  • 2013 Tier One Auto Musial Kaline Mattingly

2013 Tier One: $61.00

2013 Tier One Auto Musial Kaline Mattingly

  • 🔥DON MATTINGLY 2019 TOPPS DEFINITIVE ON CARD AUTOGRAPH #225-YANKEES

🔥DON MATTINGLY 2019: $18.50

🔥DON MATTINGLY 2019 TOPPS DEFINITIVE ON CARD AUTOGRAPH #225-YANKEES

  • 2019 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly 0750 Auto

2019 Topps Museum: $124.95

2019 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly 0750 Auto

  • Don Mattingly Yankees Legend 1968 Style Painted Portrait Card 11

Don Mattingly Yankees: $24.99

Don Mattingly Yankees Legend 1968 Style Painted Portrait Card 11

  • 1995 LEAF STATISTICAL STANDOUTS LOT**MATTINGLY - PUCKET**5 CARDS**NM-MINT**

1995 LEAF STATISTICAL: $34.99

1995 LEAF STATISTICAL STANDOUTS LOT**MATTINGLY - PUCKET**5 CARDS**NM-MINT**

  • 1984 Fleer Baseball Complete 660 Card Set Strawberry Mattingly Rookie

1984 Fleer Baseball: $45.00

1984 Fleer Baseball Complete 660 Card Set Strawberry Mattingly Rookie

  • Lot of 80s rookie cards- 4 Mattingly 1 Canseco 1 Gwynn 2 Sandberg- all timers

Lot of 80s: $29.99

Lot of 80s rookie cards- 4 Mattingly 1 Canseco 1 Gwynn 2 Sandberg- all timers

  • 2019 Topps Definitive Don Mattingly New York Yankees On Card Auto 1325

2019 Topps Definitive: $45.00

2019 Topps Definitive Don Mattingly New York Yankees On Card Auto 1325

  • MATTINGLY MCGRIFF 93 LEAF GOLD STARS BGS 9.5

MATTINGLY MCGRIFF 93: $15.00

MATTINGLY MCGRIFF 93 LEAF GOLD STARS BGS 9.5

  •  1984 DONRUSS BASEBALL #248 DON MATTINGLY RC - NMMT

1984 DONRUSS BASEBALL: $29.99

1984 DONRUSS BASEBALL #248 DON MATTINGLY RC - NMMT

  • Ruth Mantle Jeter Munson Mattingly Berra O'Neill + 2019 Leaf Ultimate Relic #24

Ruth Mantle Jeter: $76.00

Ruth Mantle Jeter Munson Mattingly Berra O'Neill + 2019 Leaf Ultimate Relic #24

  • 1984 Donruss #248 - Don Mattingly - nm-mt+ SGC 92 PSA 8.5 - ROOKIE

1984 Donruss #248: $48.00

1984 Donruss #248 - Don Mattingly - nm-mt+ SGC 92 PSA 8.5 - ROOKIE

  • 2019 Museum Archival Autographs Cal Ripken Jr. & Don Mattingly Dual AUTO 0615

2019 Museum Archival: $73.00

2019 Museum Archival Autographs Cal Ripken Jr. & Don Mattingly Dual AUTO 0615

  • 2019 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly Framed Auto #0115 Yankees Autograph

2019 Topps Museum: $86.00

2019 Topps Museum Collection Don Mattingly Framed Auto #0115 Yankees Autograph

  • 1984 Topps Don Mattingly - Rookie - New York Yankees!

1984 Topps Don: $14.95

1984 Topps Don Mattingly - Rookie - New York Yankees!

  • Don Mattingly 1989 Topps Double Headers Mets Yankees TEST with Wrapper TOUGH

Don Mattingly 1989: $57.99

Don Mattingly 1989 Topps Double Headers Mets Yankees TEST with Wrapper TOUGH

  • 1985 FLEER #133 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10

1985 FLEER #133: $116.95

1985 FLEER #133 DON MATTINGLY YANKEES PSA 10

  • Huge Baseball Unopened Wax Pack Lot of 105 w 1984 Fleer Pack Mattingly RC?

Huge Baseball Unopened: $22.99

Huge Baseball Unopened Wax Pack Lot of 105 w 1984 Fleer Pack Mattingly RC?

  • 1988 Topps Tiffany PSA 10 GEM MINT Cards Dave Winfield #510 Don Mattingly #300

1988 Topps Tiffany: $39.00

1988 Topps Tiffany PSA 10 GEM MINT Cards Dave Winfield #510 Don Mattingly #300

  • 2015 Topps Archives #276 Don Mattingly PSA 10 *1185

2015 Topps Archives: $17.99

2015 Topps Archives #276 Don Mattingly PSA 10 *1185

  • 2006 Topps Sterling Don Mattingly Auto  game used  310 autograph 1989  ON CARD

2006 Topps Sterling: $110.00

2006 Topps Sterling Don Mattingly Auto  game used 310 autograph 1989  ON CARD

  • 1987 Topps Tiffany Trademark On Front #606 Don Mattingly PSA 9 MINT

1987 Topps Tiffany: $13.54

1987 Topps Tiffany Trademark On Front #606 Don Mattingly PSA 9 MINT

  • 1984 Topps Don Mattingly Rookie #8 BCCG 10

1984 Topps Don: $29.98

1984 Topps Don Mattingly Rookie #8 BCCG 10

  • Don Mattingly 2003 Leaf Limited Lumberjacks-game used bat card LJ-6 #2525

Don Mattingly 2003: $14.99

Don Mattingly 2003 Leaf Limited Lumberjacks-game used bat card LJ-6 #2525

  • 1996 Topps Chrome #56 Refractor Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 9 MINT

1996 Topps Chrome: $49.99

1996 Topps Chrome #56 Refractor Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 9 MINT

  • 2019 topps Don Mattingly game used memorabilia bat

2019 topps Don: $14.99

2019 topps Don Mattingly game used memorabilia bat

  • 1984 DONRUSS Baseball Factory Sealed Complete Set-Don Mattingly RC *No Reserve*

1984 DONRUSS Baseball: $97.66

1984 DONRUSS Baseball Factory Sealed Complete Set-Don Mattingly RC *No Reserve*

  • 10 Baseball Set: BRETT RIPKEN MATTINGLY ROSE RYAN MURRAY SCHMIDT HENDERSON TROUT

10 Baseball Set:: $29.00

10 Baseball Set: BRETT RIPKEN MATTINGLY ROSE RYAN MURRAY SCHMIDT HENDERSON TROUT

  • 1984 TOPPS #8 DON MATTINGLY RC YANKEES PSA 9 B2673921-912

1984 TOPPS #8: $37.99

1984 TOPPS #8 DON MATTINGLY RC YANKEES PSA 9 B2673921-912

  • 1984 Donruss Don Mattingly ROOKIE RC #248 PSA 9 MINT (PWCC)

1984 Donruss Don: $99.00

1984 Donruss Don Mattingly ROOKIE RC #248 PSA 9 MINT (PWCC)

  • JETER  MATTINGLY 2005 UD REFLECTIONS DUAL YANKEES GAME PATCH COMBO #6699 K8596

JETER MATTINGLY: $24.99

JETER MATTINGLY 2005 UD REFLECTIONS DUAL YANKEES GAME PATCH COMBO #6699 K8596

  • 1992 Z Silk Cachets Don Mattingly Card Extremely Rare No Envelope Attached

1992 Z Silk: $43.99

1992 Z Silk Cachets Don Mattingly Card Extremely Rare No Envelope Attached

  • Sports Memorabilia  Autographed and framed Don Mattingly

Sports Memorabilia  Autographed: $25.00

Sports Memorabilia  Autographed and framed Don Mattingly "Hit Man"

  • Huge Baseball Unopened Wax Pack Lot of 105 w 1984 Topps Pack Mattingly RC?

Huge Baseball Unopened: $22.99

Huge Baseball Unopened Wax Pack Lot of 105 w 1984 Topps Pack Mattingly RC?

  • 1991 Leaf Don Mattingly #425 New York Yankees PSA 10

1991 Leaf Don: $14.99

1991 Leaf Don Mattingly #425 New York Yankees PSA 10

  • 2018 Topps Gallery Blue Don Mattingly #0750  New York Yankees Rare!

2018 Topps Gallery: $39.99

2018 Topps Gallery Blue Don Mattingly #0750 New York Yankees Rare!

  • (16) 1984 TOPPS DON MATTINGLY #8 ROOKIE LOT NM-MT YANKEES VL1614

(16) 1984 TOPPS: $84.99

(16) 1984 TOPPS DON MATTINGLY #8 ROOKIE LOT NM-MT YANKEES VL1614

  • 2018 Topps Living Set DON MATTINGLY Yankees PSA 10 Gem Mint

2018 Topps Living: $25.00

2018 Topps Living Set DON MATTINGLY Yankees PSA 10 Gem Mint

  • 1984 Nestle Don Mattingly - Ultimate One-of-a-kind PSA 10 Lot

1984 Nestle Don: $1,600.00

1984 Nestle Don Mattingly - Ultimate One-of-a-kind PSA 10 Lot

  • Don mattingly Gold Mirror! Super rare!

Don mattingly Gold: $15.00

Don mattingly Gold Mirror! Super rare!

  • DON MATTINGLY 2007 Upper Deck UD Premier Remnants Game Used Jersey Relic 0535

DON MATTINGLY 2007: $34.99

DON MATTINGLY 2007 Upper Deck UD Premier Remnants Game Used Jersey Relic 0535

  • (103) Don Mattingly lot 1984 - 1993 (RC + others) see Photos

(103) Don Mattingly: $13.00

(103) Don Mattingly lot 1984 - 1993 (RC + others) see Photos

  • 1984 Topps #8 Don Mattingly New York Yankees RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT

1984 Topps #8: $152.50

1984 Topps #8 Don Mattingly New York Yankees RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT

  • 1991 Topps Stadium Club # 21 DON MATTINGLY Gem Mint PSA 10 New York Yankees

1991 Topps Stadium: $29.99

1991 Topps Stadium Club # 21 DON MATTINGLY Gem Mint PSA 10 New York Yankees

  • 1984 TOPPS TIFFANY #8 DON MATTINGLY RC~RARE~CLEAN~SHARP...

1984 TOPPS TIFFANY: $49.99

1984 TOPPS TIFFANY #8 DON MATTINGLY RC~RARE~CLEAN~SHARP...

  • Don Mattingly - PSA 10 Gem Mint - 1983 Topps All Star #386 - POP 67!  Free Ship!

Don Mattingly -: $29.99

Don Mattingly - PSA 10 Gem Mint - 1983 Topps All Star #386 - POP 67! Free Ship!

  • 2019 Topps Museum Collection-Archival Autograph DON MATTINGLY

2019 Topps Museum: $75.00

2019 Topps Museum Collection-Archival Autograph DON MATTINGLY

  • Don Mattingly 2015 Topps Five Star Golden Graphs Signature Auto 3050 Gold Ink

Don Mattingly 2015: $20.74

Don Mattingly 2015 Topps Five Star Golden Graphs Signature Auto 3050 Gold Ink

  • 1984 FLEER #131 DON MATTINGLY RC YANKEES PSA 10 Rookie

1984 FLEER #131: $339.95

1984 FLEER #131 DON MATTINGLY RC YANKEES PSA 10 Rookie

  • 1984 Baseball Card Lot - Darryl Strawberry RC & Don Mattingly RC

1984 Baseball Card: $20.00

1984 Baseball Card Lot - Darryl Strawberry RC & Don Mattingly RC

  • 1991 Sargento Mootown Snackers Baseball Factory Set Griffey JR  Yount  Mattingly

1991 Sargento Mootown: $14.99

1991 Sargento Mootown Snackers Baseball Factory Set Griffey JR Yount Mattingly

  • 2014 Topps Five Star Silver Sig Don Mattingly On Card AUTO Autograph 50 Yankees

2014 Topps Five: $44.99

2014 Topps Five Star Silver Sig Don Mattingly On Card AUTO Autograph 50 Yankees

  • Don Mattingly George Brett Wade Boggs Signed AUTO 8x10 Photo JSA COA

Don Mattingly George: $44.00

Don Mattingly George Brett Wade Boggs Signed AUTO 8x10 Photo JSA COA

  • 1984 Donruss Don Mattingly ROOKIE RC #248 PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

1984 Donruss Don: $840.00

1984 Donruss Don Mattingly ROOKIE RC #248 PSA 10 GEM MINT (PWCC)

  • 2019 Topps Museum Cal Ripken Jr - Don Mattingly Dual Auto of LEGENDS 1215

2019 Topps Museum: $559.00

2019 Topps Museum Cal Ripken Jr - Don Mattingly Dual Auto of LEGENDS 1215

  • 1984 Donruss Baseball Complete Set - Don Mattingly Rookie

1984 Donruss Baseball: $69.00

1984 Donruss Baseball Complete Set - Don Mattingly Rookie

  • 1987 Topps Tiffany #500 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 9 MINT

1987 Topps Tiffany: $19.00

1987 Topps Tiffany #500 Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 9 MINT

  • 1980s Topps Rookie Lot Of 6!! 80 Rickey 83 Sandberg 83 Gwynn 84 Mattingly NM!

1980s Topps Rookie: $75.00

1980s Topps Rookie Lot Of 6!! 80 Rickey 83 Sandberg 83 Gwynn 84 Mattingly NM!

  • Lot of (17) 1984 Topps Baseball Rack Packs - MattinglyStrawberry RC's

Lot of (17): $101.43

Lot of (17) 1984 Topps Baseball Rack Packs - MattinglyStrawberry RC's

  • 2019 Topps Museum Dona Mattingly Jumbo Lumber Bat Nameplate Relics 11

2019 Topps Museum: $127.50

2019 Topps Museum Dona Mattingly Jumbo Lumber Bat Nameplate Relics 11

  • Don Mattingly 2017 Topps Silver Pack Orange Mojo Refractor 99 Yankees

Don Mattingly 2017: $44.99

Don Mattingly 2017 Topps Silver Pack Orange Mojo Refractor 99 Yankees